General Contractors vs. Kitchen Remodeling Contractors: Which One Do You Need?

Derek Obringer • March 27, 2025

General Contractors vs. Kitchen Remodelers: Key Differences


When planning your kitchen renovation, choosing the right professional is crucial. Should you hire a general contractor or a kitchen remodeling contractor? While both handle renovations, their expertise and scope of work differ significantly.


General Contractors


General contractors oversee large-scale remodeling projects, such as whole-home renovations or additions. They handle structural changes, electrical and plumbing work, and permit approvals. Because they manage multiple subcontractors and coordinate various trades, hiring a general contractor is typically more expensive. They are best suited for projects that go beyond just the kitchen.


Kitchen Remodeling Contractors


Kitchen remodelers specialize in kitchen-specific renovations, focusing on layout, design, and materials. They often work directly on the kitchen, rather than overseeing multiple subcontractors. Because their expertise is limited to one area of the home, they provide more cost-effective solutions for homeowners looking to upgrade their kitchens without altering other spaces.


Which One Do You Need?


If your project involves multiple rooms or structural changes, a general contractor is the best choice. However, if your renovation is kitchen-focused and you want a more budget-friendly approach, a kitchen remodeling contractor is the way to go. Understanding these differences can help you make the right decision for your home renovation needs.



Key Differences: General Contractors vs. Kitchen Remodelers


When planning a home renovation, it's essential to understand the key differences between general contractors and kitchen remodelers to ensure you hire the right professional for the job. While both play crucial roles in home improvement, their scope of work, expertise, cost, and project management styles vary significantly.


1. Scope of Work


The primary difference between a general contractor and a kitchen remodeler is the scope of work they handle:


General Contractors: General contractors oversee broad renovation projects that may involve multiple rooms, entire home remodels, or structural changes. Their responsibilities often include:

Managing large-scale renovations, including home expansions and floor plan modifications.

Overseeing structural changes such as removing walls or adding new rooms.

 Coordinating various subcontractors, such as electricians, plumbers, and carpenters, to complete the project efficiently.


Kitchen Remodelers: Kitchen remodelers, on the other hand, specialize exclusively in kitchen renovations. Their work is focused on:

Optimizing kitchen layout design for better functionality and efficiency.

Installing cabinetry, countertops, backsplashes, and appliances.

Choosing the best materials, finishes, and storage solutions for an aesthetically pleasing and practical kitchen.

If your project involves multiple rooms or structural modifications, a general contractor is necessary. However, if your focus is solely on updating or redesigning the kitchen, a kitchen remodeler is the better choice.


2. Expertise & Specialization


The level of expertise required for a renovation depends on the type and complexity of the project.


General Contractors: These professionals have broad knowledge across multiple trades, including:

Structural modifications (e.g., knocking down walls or adding load-bearing beams).

Electrical and plumbing work to support home expansions.

Permitting and building code compliance for large-scale projects.

Kitchen Remodelers: In contrast, kitchen remodelers focus specifically on kitchen design, materials, and functionality, which includes:

Understanding the latest kitchen trends and space-saving solutions.

Customizing cabinets, countertops, and islands for improved workflow.

Ensuring optimal appliance placement to enhance efficiency.

If your renovation requires significant structural changes, a general contractor is the right choice. However, if you want a kitchen tailored to your lifestyle and design preferences, a kitchen remodeler's specialized knowledge is more beneficial.


3. Cost Considerations


Cost is a major factor when choosing between a general contractor and a kitchen remodeler.


General Contractor:


In most cases, they will charge a percentage of the total project cost, often ranging between 10% and 25%.

Their services are more expensive due to the larger scale of work and involvement of multiple trades.

Costs may include permits, labor for structural changes, and extensive material selections.


Kitchen Remodeling Company:


Offer a more budget-friendly option for homeowners focusing solely on the kitchen.

Since they specialize in one area, their labor and material costs are often more predictable and controlled.

Homeowners can choose from different levels of renovation, from minor upgrades to high-end, custom kitchen designs.

If you're planning a whole-home remodel or structural work, a general contractor's higher costs are justified. However, if you need a cost-effective kitchen transformation, a kitchen remodeler is the smarter financial choice.


4. Project & Subcontractor Management


Managing a renovation project requires careful coordination, and the approach differs between general contractors and kitchen remodelers.


General Contractor:


  • Act as project manager, hiring and overseeing subcontractors for various tasks such as flooring, plumbing, and HVAC installation.
  • Ensure all trades work in sync to meet project deadlines.
  • Handle any unexpected construction challenges, such as hidden electrical issues or outdated plumbing.


Kitchen Remodeling Company:


  • Typically, they work with a smaller, more specialized team of designers and craftsmen.
  • Provide a hands-on approach by focusing on specific kitchen elements, ensuring quality control throughout the project.
  • May still work with subcontractors (e.g., electricians or plumbers) but on a much smaller scale than general contractors.
  • If your renovation involves multiple professionals across different areas, a general contractor is necessary. However, if you prefer a more direct and focused approach for your kitchen, a kitchen remodeler provides the expertise needed.


Both general contractors and kitchen remodelers bring valuable skills to the table, but their expertise is suited for different types of projects.

When to Hire a General Contractor vs. a Kitchen Remodeler


One of the most important decisions you'll make is whether to hire a general contractor or a specialized kitchen remodeler. The right choice depends on your project's scope, budget, and timeline.

When to Hire a General Contractor

A general contractor is best for large-scale renovations that go beyond just the kitchen. If your project involves structural changes, electrical and plumbing upgrades, or full additions to your home, a general contractor can oversee the project's entire process. They coordinate multiple subcontractors and ensure everything is built to code. 

While this option tends to be more expensive, it's necessary for complex remodels that require permits and extensive construction.

When a Kitchen Remodeler Is the Better Option

If your project is focused solely on updating your kitchen, a specialized kitchen remodeler is often the smarter choice. These professionals have expertise in kitchen design, materials, and layout improvements. They handle tasks like cabinetry, countertops, backsplashes, and appliance installation. Since they don't manage unrelated trades, hiring a kitchen remodeler is usually more budget-friendly and leads to a faster project timeline.

Key Factors to Consider

  • Budget – General contractors are typically more expensive due to their broad scope, while kitchen remodelers offer cost-effective solutions for kitchen-only upgrades.
  • Timeline – Kitchen remodelers can often complete projects more quickly since they focus on a single area, whereas general contractors may have longer timelines due to managing multiple trades.
  • Project Size – If your renovation involves other areas of the home, structural changes, or major system upgrades, a general contractor is necessary. For a kitchen-focused update, a remodeler is usually the better fit.


Cost Considerations: General Contractors vs. Kitchen Remodelers


Budget plays a critical role in any home renovation, and understanding how pricing structures differ between general contractors and kitchen remodeling specialists can help you make an informed decision. The overall cost of your project will depend on several key factors, including labor, materials, and necessary permits.

Pricing Structures: General Contractors vs. Kitchen Remodelers

  • General Contractors: These professionals typically manage large-scale renovations and work with multiple subcontractors across different trades. Their pricing is usually structured as a fixed contract price or a cost-plus model, where they charge for materials and labor plus a markup. Since they oversee the entire project, their fees often include project management costs and subcontractor coordination, leading to higher overall expenses.
  • Kitchen Remodeling Specialists: Unlike general contractors, kitchen remodelers focus solely on kitchen renovations. They may charge you a flat fee for the entire project or bill separately based on labor and materials. Because they work within a smaller scope, they tend to have lower overhead costs, making these services more budget-friendly for kitchen-only remodels.

Factors That Impact Costs

Several elements contribute to the total price of your kitchen renovation, regardless of whether you hire a general contractor or a kitchen remodeler.

  1. Materials – The quality and type of remodeling materials you choose will significantly affect your budget. High-end countertops (e.g., quartz or marble), custom cabinetry, and luxury appliances will drive up costs. At the same time, budget-friendly alternatives like laminate counters or stock cabinets can help keep expenses in check.
  2. Labor Costs – General contractors typically work with a team of subcontractors, meaning labor costs can be higher due to multiple trades involved in the project. Kitchen remodelers, on the other hand, often handle more aspects of the renovation themselves or work with a smaller team, resulting in lower labor costs.
  3. Permits and Inspections – Structural changes, electrical upgrades, and plumbing modifications often require permits, which add to the overall expense. General contractors typically manage this process, but the costs are passed on to the homeowner. Kitchen remodelers, depending on the project scope, may have fewer permit-related expenses if no major structural work is involved.
  4. Project Complexity – A simple kitchen facelift (e.g., cabinet refacing, new countertops, and fresh paint) will be significantly less expensive than a full-scale renovation that involves knocking down walls, relocating plumbing, or upgrading electrical systems.
  5. Timeline and Project Scope – Larger renovations involving multiple rooms take longer to complete, leading to increased labor costs and potential disruptions. Kitchen remodeling specialists often complete projects faster, which can reduce labor expenses and overall inconvenience.

Making the Right Choice for Your Budget

If your renovation involves extensive structural work or home-wide updates, hiring a general contractor is necessary, but it comes at a higher cost. If you're looking for a cost-effective way to update your kitchen without affecting other areas of your home, a kitchen remodeler offers a more streamlined and budget-friendly option. Understanding these cost factors will help you allocate your budget wisely and achieve the best results for your renovation.

Why Choose Obringer's Painting & Remodeling?


When it comes to kitchen renovations, you need a team with experience, craftsmanship, and a commitment to customer satisfaction.


Obringer's Painting & Remodeling stands out as a trusted name in the industry, offering:


Expert Kitchen Design & Craftsmanship: From modern updates to timeless styles, our team specializes in creating stunning, functional kitchen spaces tailored to your needs.


Quality Materials & Workmanship: We use only high-quality materials, ensuring your kitchen remodel stands the test of time.


Affordable, Transparent Pricing: We provide clear estimates with no hidden costs, helping you get the best value for your investment.

Personalized Service & Attention to Detail – Every project is handled with care, and we work closely with homeowners to bring their vision to life.


Timely Project Completion: Our team is dedicated to finishing projects efficiently without sacrificing quality so you can enjoy your new kitchen sooner.


Call Obringer's Today for Your Next Kitchen Remodel!


Ready to transform your kitchen? Contact Obringer's Painting & Remodeling today for a consultation with a kitchen renovation expert who can bring your vision to life. 


Whether you're making small updates or planning a complete remodel, our team is here to deliver exceptional results with expert craftsmanship and outstanding service. Let's create the kitchen of your dreams!

silhoette

Author: Derek Obringer


Owner & Founder of Obringer's Painting and Remodeling, Derek Obringer brings attention to detail, together with experience, and superior customer service into each and every home that his company does work.

Painting And Remodeling Blog

woman in her kitchen with an inquisitive look as she ponders kitchen remodeling
By Derek Obringer October 15, 2025
Considering a kitchen remodel? Be sure that you have thought it through! Contact Obringers for kitchen design tips, expert service and quality workmanship today!
high powered fan drying out flooring underlayment after a plumbing accident
By Derek Obringer September 10, 2025
A kitchen remodel is one of the most rewarding projects a homeowner can take on. Not only does it transform the look and feel of your home, but it also improves daily life in one of the most-used spaces. As exciting as it is to pick out new cabinets, countertops, and finishes, there are also bigger layout decisions to consider. One of the biggest questions is whether or not to move the plumbing. Relocating a sink, dishwasher, or refrigerator line can give you the freedom to create a more functional layout, but it also comes with added cost and complexity. What Moving Plumbing Involves During Kitchen Remodeling At first, "moving plumbing" might sound as simple as shifting a sink from one wall to another. In reality, the process can range from a minor adjustment to a major reconfiguration. For example, you hire a kitchen remodeling company and you decide to add a dishwasher next to an existing sink , the job may only involve extending a water line a few feet. On the other hand, if you want to move the sink to an island in the middle of the kitchen , that requires running new supply and drain lines, cutting into the floor, and ensuring the drain has the proper slope. Common Plumbing components that might be moved during a remodel include: The sink – often the most significant change, since it involves both water supply and drainage. The dishwasher – usually placed near the sink, but still requires water and drain connections. Refrigerator water line – simpler to move, but still involves rerouting plumbing through walls or floors. Gas lines – if you're shifting a range or cooktop, this adds a layer of coordination. Each of these comes with its own level of difficulty, which is why consulting a professional early in the design process is essential. Cost Considerations For Plumbing Relocation The cost of moving plumbing can vary dramatically depending on the scope of work. On average, homeowners spend $500 to $3,000 per fixture, but the final price can swing higher or lower depending on the complexity of the project. Several factors drive the cost: Distance of the move: Shifting a sink a couple of feet is far less expensive than relocating it across the room. The further the lines need to be rerouted, the more labor is involved. Foundation type: Homes with crawl spaces or basements often make the job easier since plumbers can access the underside of the floor. Homes built on concrete slabs, however, may require cutting into concrete, which significantly increases labor and cost. Structural modifications: Moving plumbing isn't just about pipes. It may involve removing cabinets, cutting into walls, or modifying flooring and joists. These additional steps add both time and expense. Permits and inspections: Most municipalities, including those around Pittsburgh, require permits for plumbing changes. While permits add cost, they also ensure the work is done safely and to code. Local labor rates: As with any skilled trade, rates vary depending on where you live. In a metro area like Pittsburgh, you may pay more than in smaller or more rural towns, but you'll also benefit from experienced contractors familiar with complex remodels. For budget-conscious homeowners, it's important to factor in the plumbing costs and how they affect the overall remodel budget. Benefits of Moving Plumbing The main reason homeowners consider moving plumbing is flexibility. By not being locked into your current layout , you can design a kitchen that better matches your lifestyle. For example, moving the sink to an island makes it easy to interact with your family or guests while working in the kitchen, rather than facing a wall. Similarly, adding a prep sink near the refrigerator creates a more efficient workspace for multiple cooks in the kitchen. Other advantages include: Opportunity to add modern features : Whether it's a pot filler above the stove or a second dishwasher for large families, moving plumbing allows for upgrades that make daily life more convenient. Resale value : Buyers are often drawn to kitchens with functional layouts. A remodel that transforms a cramped, awkward space into an open, user-friendly design can help your home stand out in the Pittsburgh market. Improved workflow : The classic "work triangle" between the sink, stove, and refrigerator is still a gold standard for efficiency. Moving plumbing often makes it easier to achieve that balance. Cons of Moving Plumbing Of course, the benefits come with trade-offs. The most obvious downside is cost. Even a relatively minor move can add thousands of dollars to your remodeling budget. Another drawback is time. Extending a project to reroute plumbing may add days or weeks to the timeline, especially if inspections are required or if multiple trades need to coordinate. This can be frustrating if you're hoping to complete the remodel quickly. There's also the risk of surprises. Once walls and floors are opened up, contractors may discover old or corroded pipes, hidden wiring, or structural challenges. These issues can lead to additional costs that weren't part of the initial plan. Lastly, moving plumbing often requires more than just a plumber. Carpenters, electricians, and sometimes even concrete contractors may need to get involved, adding layers of scheduling and expense. When It's Worth It Despite the challenges, there are situations where moving plumbing is well worth the investment, but at the end of the day, only you can make that decision When the existing layout is dysfunctional : If your sink is in a dark corner or your appliances are spread too far apart, relocating plumbing can dramatically improve daily use. When doing a full gut remodel, if you're already tearing the kitchen down to the studs, the added cost of moving plumbing may be minimal compared to the overall project. When you plan to stay long-term : If you'll enjoy the convenience and functionality of the new layout for years, the investment pays off in comfort and quality of life. When resale value justifies it: In neighborhoods where buyers expect high-end kitchens, the cost may be recouped when you sell your home. When to Avoid Plumbing Relocation On the other hand, moving plumbing may not make sense in every situation. If your remodel is primarily cosmetic, for example, replacing cabinets, countertops, and flooring without altering the layout — then keeping plumbing in place helps you stretch your budget further. It's also wise to avoid significant plumbing changes if you're on a tight timeline. For instance, if you're remodeling before putting your house on the market, spending extra time and money on a new layout may not deliver a high enough return on investment. And if your existing layout is already functional, you may find that updating finishes provides the fresh look you want without the added cost and hassle. Expert Tips Before You Decide Before you make a final decision, keep these tips in mind: Consult a licensed plumber before committing to a new layout. They can tell you what's feasible and what potential obstacles exist. Get multiple quotes. Costs can vary, and comparing estimates helps you understand the realistic price range for your project. Ask about permits. Requirements differ from one municipality to another, but you'll want to be sure your remodel complies with local codes. Consider partial moves. Sometimes extending a line or making a slight adjustment achieves the functionality you want without a complete relocation. Work with an experienced contractor. Professional kitchen contractors in Pittsburgh understand how to balance design goals, code requirements, and budgets to deliver the best results. Call Obringer's Today to Plan Your Kitchen Remodel in Pittsburgh Deciding whether to move plumbing during a kitchen remodel is ultimately about balancing cost with long-term value. While it's not always necessary, moving plumbing can transform a kitchen into a more functional, modern, and appealing space. For homeowners in Pittsburgh, the key is to weigh the current limitations of your kitchen against your remodeling goals and budget. If your layout truly holds you back, the investment may be well worth it. Focusing on high-quality finishes and smart updates might be the smarter choice. At Obringer's Painting & Remodeling, we help homeowners make these decisions every day. Our team provides professional kitchen remodeling services in Pittsburgh, guiding you from design to completion with expertise and care. Ready to explore your options? Contact Obringer's today to schedule a consultation with trusted kitchen contractors in Pittsburgh.
White bathroom color scheme with a glass shower featuring marble tile walls
By Derek Obringer August 19, 2025
Discover the benefits of wet area remodeling with Obringers! Upgrade your bathroom affordably by starting where it matters most. Contact us today!
his and hers sinks in a beautiful bathroom remodeled by Obringer's Painting and Remodeling
By Derek Obringer July 28, 2025
Read along for inspiration on your next bathroom remodel! Contact Obringer's for expertise and craftsmanship in the Pittsburgh area!
TV entertainment area and pool table in a finished basement
By Derek Obringer June 27, 2025
Finishing your basement can be a smooth process, but sometimes the unknowns and a blank slate before you can be daunting. Check out these tips, and give us a call!
Beautifully remodeled kitchen with blue cabinets, butcher block countertop and stainless steel kitchen appliances
By Derek Obringer May 21, 2025
Discover what a kitchen remodel can cost you, and prioritize the areas that matter most! Call Obringer's for expert painting and remodeling services for your kitchen!
bathroom remodeling contractors installing an under sink cabinet in a bathroom.
By Derek Obringer February 26, 2025
Bathroom remodeling on a budget does present challenges, but if you prioritize, and work with a contractor committed to your project, its much easier. Call Obringer's today!
kitchen blue print fading into finished kitchen remodel
By Derek Obringer January 27, 2025
Are you looking to get started on your kitchen remodel but are unsure of where to start? Read these tips from Obringer's and call with any questions!
freshly remodeled kitchen
By Derek Obringer December 18, 2024
Many people are tempted to tackle the kitchen remodel themselves. You may have the skills required, but learn what can get in your way without the proper experience.
kitchen example
By Derek Obringer November 26, 2024
Ever wondered the different parts and components that make up your kitchen cabinets? Learn today with Obringers Painting & Remodeling!